Menu Close Menu

If the crime charged doesn't fit the facts of the case, should a judge dismiss it?

Posted by Nathan Webb on Sep 25, 2015 | 0 Comments

Many times I see people charged with crimes ranging from Theft to, of course, DUI and the facts alleged in the police report simply don't add up to the elements of the crime charged. Take for example a recent case I had wherein a client was charged with Hit and Run of an Attended Vehicle (RCW 46.52.020) in addition to DUI.  The victim stated to police the individual who struck her acknowledged he hit her vehicle and invited her to follow him to his business, which was just a few feet away from the accident, to exchange information.  Moments later, the police went inside the business location and arrested the individual for DUI and Hit and Run.  We filed motions to suppress based upon the ruling in State v. Knapstad and the court granted the dismissal of the Hit and Run (click here to see press write-up).  Our preliminary motions filed assisted this client in having one of the charges dismissed.  

When the facts don't add up to the charge, it is essential your attorney is skilled and knowledgeable enough to know what to file and when.  Here it saved this client a further license suspension and potential for jail.

The ruling in State v. Knapstad essentially stands for the proposition that even assuming the facts in the police report are true, it doesn't establish a case under the charged crime.  So in the example above, Hit and Run, the individual did not knowingly strike someone and leave the scene without leaving information, quite the contrary, as the judge concluded, he invited her into his business just a few feet away after acknowledging the accident.  

About the Author

Nathan Webb

Nathan "Nate" Webb has been repeatedly recognized by Washington Law and Politics Magazine as a Super Lawyer Rising Star, named one of Seattle's Top Attorneys by Seattle Met Magazine and is rated Superb (perfect 10 out of 10) by Avvo.com.

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Nathan Webb, Attorney at Law

Webb-logo-dark

Nathan Webb is a Superb-rated Seattle Attorney by Avvo.com and has been repeatedly named a SuperLawyer Rising Star and recognized as a "Top Attorney" in Washington State by Seattle Met Magazine. He helps people with Auto Accident Injury claims, Social Security Disability Claims, DUI charges and civil traffic offenses throughout the Greater Seattle Metro Area

Free Confidential Consultation

Mr. Webb offers a free confidential initial consultation to discuss your case and review your options and rights. Contact Mr. Webb today to schedule your meeting.